Cheese and Garlic Crack Bread Recipe

You know that moment when you bring something to a party and suddenly there’s a small crowd hovering around it? That’s exactly what happens with this Cheese and Garlic Crack Bread. Trust me, I’ve watched my normally polite friends transform into competitive food-grabbers within seconds of setting this down. There’s something almost magical about pulling off those cheesy, buttery pieces while the cheese stretches into those perfect, photo-worthy pulls.

This isn’t just ordinary garlic bread – it’s an interactive food experience that brings people together (before they start playfully elbowing each other for the last piece). The combination of stretchy mozzarella, garlicky butter, crispy edges, and soft centers hits all those comfort food notes we crave. I’ve literally seen people’s eyes light up when they take their first bite.

Recipe Highlights

• The flavor experience: Think warm, garlicky butter soaked into every crevice, with pockets of gooey cheese that stretch when pulled apart. The bread gets this amazing contrast of textures – crispy on top, soft inside.
• Totally doable: Don’t let the impressive looks fool you – if you can use a knife and drizzle butter, you’ve got this covered.
• Pro tip from my kitchen: Cut your bread on a cutting board, not in the foil. You’ll have much better control and won’t accidentally slice through the bottom.
• My time-saving hack: I often cream softened butter with the garlic instead of melting it, then spread it into the first cuts before making the crosscuts. Works like a charm when I’m in a hurry!

Why You’ll Love This Cheesy Garlic Bread

• It uses just 5 simple ingredients most of us already have at home
• No fancy equipment needed – just a knife and some foil
• Makes everyone think you spent way more time than you actually did
• Creates those fun moments where everyone’s reaching in together
• You can prep it ahead when you’re juggling other party tasks
• Adapts easily to whatever flavors you’re in the mood for
• I’ve never once brought this home with leftovers – it vanishes!

The Simple Ingredients That Make Magic

• A crusty loaf (sourdough or Vienna): I love sourdough for this – its sturdiness holds up perfectly when pulled apart. Vienna works great too if that’s what you have on hand.
• Mozzarella cheese: Nothing, and I mean nothing, gives you that satisfying cheese-pull moment quite like mozzarella does. That’s the money shot right there!
• Butter: This is where so much of the flavor happens – as it melts down into every nook and cranny of the bread.
• Fresh garlic: Please don’t substitute garlic powder here! Fresh minced garlic creates that intoxicating aroma that makes people’s heads turn when you bring this to the table.
• Salt: Just a touch to make all those flavors pop.
• Fresh parsley: Besides adding a pretty touch of green, it brings a hint of freshness that cuts through all that delicious richness.

You’ll find the exact measurements in the recipe card below.

How to Make Cheese and Garlic Crack Bread

1. Get That Flavor-Packed Butter Ready

Heat your oven to 350°F (180°C). Grab your butter, minced garlic, and salt and pop them in a microwave-safe bowl. I microwave it in short 10-second bursts until just melted – you don’t want it super hot. Then stir in that fresh parsley. Your kitchen already smells amazing, right?

2. The Cutting Technique (Don’t Worry, It’s Easy!)

Place your loaf on a cutting board and grab a serrated knife. This is the only slightly tricky part, but I promise it’s foolproof. Make diagonal cuts about an inch apart, but here’s the key thing I learned the hard way: don’t cut all the way through! You want the bottom crust intact to hold everything together. Then turn the loaf 90 degrees and make a second set of diagonal cuts to create a diamond pattern. The first time I did this, I found it helpful to slide my hand underneath to feel when I was getting close to cutting through.

3. Fill Those Cracks With Deliciousness

Now comes the fun part! Use your fingers (or a knife if you prefer) to gently open each crack. Drizzle about a teaspoon of your garlic butter mixture into each one. Don’t stress if it spills over – that butter that escapes to the crust actually makes for the most amazing crispy edges. Next, stuff a pinch of mozzarella into each crack. I go for the rustic approach here – no need for perfectionism, it all melts into gooey goodness anyway.

4. The Two-Stage Baking Secret

Wrap your prepped loaf completely in foil and pop it on a baking sheet. Let it bake for about 20 minutes – this first stage is all about getting that cheese melted and letting the bread soak up all that buttery goodness. Then comes the game-changer: unwrap the top (keeping the bottom still wrapped in foil) and bake for another 5-10 minutes until the top turns gloriously golden and crispy. The smell at this point will have everyone hanging around your kitchen.

5. The Big Reveal

Bring it straight to the table while it’s still warm and stretchy. I love placing it center stage and watching people’s reactions as they pull off their first piece. There’s something so satisfying about seeing those cheese pulls happen in real time – phones inevitably come out for pictures before everyone dives in.

Make It Your Own: Tasty Variations

• For Mediterranean vibes: Tuck some sun-dried tomatoes in the cracks and add dried oregano to your butter
• When I’m feeling spicy: I mix some red pepper flakes into the garlic butter – just enough for a little kick
• For meat lovers: Try tucking in small pieces of pepperoni or crispy bacon bits along with the cheese
• My three-cheese upgrade: Sometimes I mix mozzarella with provolone and a sprinkle of parmesan for more depth
• Fresh from the garden: When my herbs are thriving, I’ll skip the parsley and use a mix of rosemary, thyme, and chives

Storing and Reheating (If You Actually Have Leftovers)

• If by some miracle you have leftovers: Wrap them in foil and they’ll keep in the fridge for about 3 days.
• Bringing it back to life: For that fresh-baked taste, wrap in foil and warm in a 350°F oven for about 10 minutes. In a rush? Microwave individual pieces for 15-20 seconds.
• Make-ahead option #1: You can prep everything up to adding the cheese, then refrigerate for up to 24 hours. I’ve even frozen it at this stage for up to a month (just thaw completely before baking).
• Make-ahead option #2: When I’m really planning ahead, I’ll fully bake it, let it cool, wrap tightly, and refrigerate. A quick 1.5-2 minutes in the microwave brings it back to life.

Tips From My Kitchen to Yours

• The bread matters: I learned this through trial and error – denser bread holds up better. Those light, airy loaves tend to collapse too much.
• Room temperature ingredients work best: When I take the time to let my butter soften naturally, it mixes more evenly with the garlic and herbs.
• My cutting hack: A good serrated knife makes such a difference when cutting through crusty bread without squishing it.
• Don’t skimp on the filling: Make sure you get cheese into every single crack – nothing’s sadder than pulling off a piece and finding no cheese!
• That crispy bottom is gold: The butter and cheese that drip down during baking create an incredible crispy bottom – my family actually fights over these pieces.
• Let it rest briefly: I’ve found letting it sit for just 3-5 minutes after baking allows the cheese to set slightly for even better stretching.

Questions People Often Ask Me

What’s the best cheese for pull-apart bread?

Mozzarella is my go-to because nothing beats its stretching ability. Those Instagram-worthy cheese pulls happen because of mozzarella’s unique protein structure. If you want to mix it up, I sometimes do 75% mozzarella plus 25% of another melty cheese like provolone or Monterey Jack for extra flavor while keeping the stretch factor.

What can I serve with this bread?

I like to balance the richness with something fresh. A simple green salad with a tangy vinaigrette works perfectly. It’s also amazing alongside a bowl of tomato soup – we dip the pieces right in. For parties, I include it on a grazing board with some olives, cold cuts, and maybe a few roasted vegetables.

Why is pull-apart bread sometimes called monkey bread?

Traditional monkey bread got its playful name because you eat it by pulling pieces with your fingers – kind of like how monkeys pick at their food. While this recipe uses a different cutting technique than classic monkey bread (which uses small balls of dough), they share that same fun, interactive eating experience that makes everyone feel like kids again.

How many calories are in each serving?

Each serving contains about 191 calories when you divide it into 10 portions. The breakdown per serving is approximately 19.5g carbs, 2.5g protein, 10.9g fat (6g saturated), and 374mg sodium. Of course, this varies depending on your bread choice and how generous you are with the cheese and butter (and I tend to be very generous with both!).

Perfect Occasions for Serving

This bread has become my go-to for so many gatherings:

• Game days – it disappears before halftime!
• Holiday appetizer spreads – a nice break from the usual cheese ball
• Potlucks – I’ve never brought home an empty dish
• Movie nights with friends – perfect for sharing while binge-watching
• Wine tastings – it pairs beautifully with both reds and whites
• Family Italian dinners – a step up from regular garlic bread
• Summer BBQs – surprisingly great alongside grilled meats

What I love most is how it instantly creates a shared experience. There’s something about everyone reaching for the same loaf, pulling off their own pieces, that creates an immediate bond – even among people who’ve just met.

When you place this golden, bubbling loaf in the center of your table, don’t be surprised when the conversation stops momentarily as everyone reaches for a piece. The first pull, revealing those perfect cheese stretches, never fails to get a reaction. Then comes that moment of biting into the perfect combination of crispy exterior and soft, flavor-packed interior.

If you make this bread, I’d love to hear your stories! Did your friends fight over the last piece like mine always do? Did you try a flavor variation that worked amazingly? Drop a comment or tag me in your photos—if you can snap one before it disappears!

For another crowd-pleaser that pairs wonderfully with this bread, check out our Quick Beetroot and Goats Cheese Quiches with Crispy Potato Cups.

Print